Mental health and AI: The second-guessing machine

AI is supposed to take the grunt of work off our plates. But it’s also giving self-doubt a new interface. 

An animated human head with colorful smoke coming out of it against a black background. The smoke is composed of different colors, creating a vibrant and dynamic effect.

Mental health and AI: The second-guessing machine   

AI is supposed to take the grunt of work off our plates. But it’s also giving self-doubt a new interface.

By Conor Nichols, Special Reporter

Thankfully, or maybe not so much these days, I write for a living and have done for a while. When generative AI started flexing its writing powers a few years ago, I was mildly impressed. Now I’m scarily impressed. I still think I’m safe, and hopefully my writing will improve faster in this AI reality than in an alternate reality in which AI doesn’t exist. 

But AI has created a strange overwhelm. Sometimes I feel like a nervy junior journalist starting out again, except the person looking over my shoulder isn’t a sub-editor, it’s an over-explaining, needy bot suggesting I tighten a paragraph I deem perfectly readable. It’s not the deadline-induced panic journalists know well. It’s quieter: seeing an AI rewrite of my own paragraph blinking at me and genuinely hesitating over whether mine is still the better one, however sizable my writer ego. It’s the nagging thought that if a tool can restructure my intro in four seconds flat, the thing I’ve spent my whole (albeit young) life getting good at might not be worth quite what I thought. 

Personal anecdote aside, I don’t think I’m unusual in feeling this. Research from the industry charity Never Not Creative recently found that job uncertainty has become the number two stressor among creative workers - higher than in any previous study it’s run. And the unease isn’t always self-inflicted, either. Instructors at the training firm Multiverse told the Guardian of “horrendous stress” after an AI system began rating their lessons, at one point flagging “digressions” that turned out to be nothing more than answering a student’s question. 

Swap “lesson” for “creative concept” or “media plan,” and I’d wager a lot of agency people reading this know the feeling too. 

That’s the gap this piece sits in. Wellbeing is a well-worn conversation in agencies. So is AI. But put the two in the same sentence and things go quiet, as though admitting AI makes you anxious is somehow an admission you’re using it wrong, or not cut out for where the industry is headed. 

To start the conversation - or at least, it feels that way from where I’m sitting - we asked people who think about workplace mental health for a living, and people running agencies through this shift in real time, a blunt question: what does AI-related stress actually look like inside a business right now, and what should agencies be doing about it? 

A workplace mental health consultancy view… 

Ada Parris

Ada Parris
Futurist, author and Chair of MHFA England

Ada Parris is a futurist, author, and Chair of MHFA England. Find out more about workplace mental health training at mhfaengland.org. 

This piece was written with Lydia McIntosh, Communications Lead, MHFA England. 

When people in agencies talk to me about AI, they usually start with what it's saved them. Hours on first drafts. Research that used to take a day. Give them a minute longer and something else comes out. A worry about whether the work they're proud of still counts for much. 

As a futurist, I'm optimistic about what these tools can do. As Chair of MHFA England, I'm also watching what they're doing to people's sense of their own worth. I think agencies are underestimating it. 

The Advertising Association's 2025 All In Census heard from more than 14,000 people. Most are keen to use AI more. But fear of being replaced falls the higher you go. Only 2% of the C-suite think their function could be fully taken over.  

The people least exposed are setting the pace for those who fear most. 

Junior staff feel it as a question about their future. The repetitive tasks they'd normally learn on are the most exposed. Senior people feel something different. They've spent years getting good at something a tool now does in seconds, and very few will admit how much that unsettles them. 

The overwhelm is rarely dramatic. Someone has four or five tools open and isn't sure which to trust. They spend the day checking outputs and making small calls about what's good enough. By lunchtime, they're tired without knowing why. Upwork found 96% of C-suite leaders expected AI to lift productivity. Yet 77% of employees using it said it had added to their workload, with reviewing AI output the biggest extra burden. 

That checking is real work. The Data Workers' Inquiry, led by data workers themselves, has shown how much AI runs on verification nobody sees or credits. Agency staff are now doing a version of it too. Some work longer hours just to prove they still add something. 

That pressure lands on an industry already stretched. Calls to NABS hit a record 5,200 in 2024, with emotional support the top reason. 

Most managers won't notice yet. They're learning the same tools under the same pressure. The early signs look like ordinary adjustment: someone going quiet in meetings, getting short with colleagues, or reworking things that were already fine. 

So invest in people who can notice. MHFA England trains people to recognise when a colleague might be struggling and to start a conversation that leads to the right support. It doesn't replace professional help, and it works best inside a wider approach to wellbeing. We've just launched the Workplace Mental Health First Aid Standards, a clear benchmark for doing this well. If you lead an agency, find out how to sign up at https://mhfaengland.org/standards-pledge/. 

Be straight about changing roles. Name which parts of the job AI will take on and where you still need human judgement. Then credit that judgement, and the checking, in who gets recognised for the work. 

Above all, don't let the speed of the tools set the pace for your people. Give them time to think and recover. Make it normal to say when things feel like too much.  

An industry mental wellness charity view… 

Annabel McCaffre

Annabel McCaffre
Head of support
NABS 

As AI becomes part of everyday working life, we're hearing more conversations about confidence, uncertainty and career development across NABS services, including coaching, workshops and the Advice Line. 

People often describe having mixed feelings. They find AI useful for tasks such as drafting, summarising and administration, but also feel uneasy about what rapid change means for their future role, skills and career prospects. 

What we're hearing isn't necessarily 'AI overwhelm' in isolation. More often, it's the broader impact of uncertainty.  

Humans naturally prefer predictability, so when job roles, expectations and ways of working are evolving quickly, it's understandable that people may feel anxious or unsettled. 

We've also seen growing interest in how people maintain their authenticity and personal brand in a world where AI is influencing how we communicate and present our work. 

For leaders, the most important thing is honest communication. Many managers are navigating the same uncertainty as their teams, and it's OK not to have all the answers. In fact, acknowledging uncertainty can help build trust. Creating space for open conversations, listening to concerns and supporting people to develop new skills can go a long way in protecting wellbeing during periods of change. 

As technology continues to evolve ever more rapidly, people's need for support, connection and psychological safety becomes even more important. 

Three agency views… 

MG OMD 

David Bratt

David Bratt
Managing Director
MG OMD 

Undoubtedly, we have all experienced Generative AI and the great opportunities it offers. Equally, many of us will have considered the existential question:  

If clever bots can complete some tasks in a fraction of the time, then what value am I adding?  

At MG OMD, our client teams increasingly use AI and automated solutions across a broad range of tasks, from quick action-point summaries, workflow management and data reconciliation, through to audience interrogation, channel scenario planning, media reporting and analysis. New possibilities continuously emerge to empower our people and help them focus on higher-value, strategic work. 

Of course, there are challenges. As humans, we are not particularly well equipped for this level of change at such a rapid pace. It is only natural to sometimes feel overwhelmed, uncertain or occasionally question where your own value fits when technology is evolving so quickly. 

In response, we have reconnected with the central tenets of a growth mindset, focusing on the learning opportunities that technology enables. When considering the decisions we recommend, we encourage our leaders and teams to ask a simple but powerful question: “What did we learn today?” 

While AI can help us move faster, it doesn't replace the human judgement clients rely on. Challenging a brief, understanding culture, building relationships and applying experience remain fundamentally human skills. Adopting a growth mindset allows MG OMD to strengthen those capabilities while embracing the opportunities AI creates. 

Lucky Generals 

Kitty Munro

Kitty Munro
People and Culture Director Lucky Generals 

There is the existential anxiety about the future of the industry and the relevance of our roles in 10, 20 years’ time that I imagine everyone suffers from occasionally, and I doubt that’s unique to advertising. 

But the overwhelm can also show up in smaller, everyday ways at work. For example, AI makes it incredibly quick and easy to send an enormous email filled with way more info than ever needed or would ever have been ‘normal’ in the past. But someone still has to read it, work out what matters and decide what needs a response. 

So something that has saved one person time has consumed more time and energy for somebody else, which can feel overwhelming. 

Of course, the other option is to just plug that email into ChatGPT and send back an equally lengthy response, which can then lead you back to that existential overwhelm of ‘what value am I bringing to this that AI can’t replicate?’ 

People at every level worry about job security, relevance and what comes next, particularly in our industry, which can feel a little tempestuous at times. AI has intensified those concerns, but I don’t see a generational divide. In fact there is something a little ageist about assuming that more senior (and likely older) people will be less adaptive to, and more nervous of, AI. We need to understand what each person is experiencing rather than make assumptions based on their age or seniority. 

Managers should be equipped to spot stress; that has always been part of managing people. The cause may be different, but the need to notice changes in someone’s behaviour remains the same. They need the training, time and confidence to start a conversation before it becomes a crisis. 

Be open about what is changing and give people a chance to talk about what it means for them. If AI is taking on repetitive tasks, people need support to see how their roles can develop. Simply telling everyone that AI will make their lives easier won’t address their concerns about where they fit. 

Keep investing in wellbeing support, including training managers to recognise stress and burnout. There’s no AI substitute for making time for someone and properly listening to them. People need to know they can raise concerns, be taken seriously and get help, whatever is causing the pressure.  

Freedom Works

Aimee Luther

Aimee Luther
Managing Director
Freedom Works 

AI can give confidence and knock it in the same afternoon.  

Getting help with something laborious can be a huge relief; wondering what that means for your own value is rather less lovely. People need to understand where their experience and judgement fit. Being able to produce something faster doesn’t mean knowing whether it’s any good. 

I’ve written before about overwhelm: that sense of carrying too much, even when you appear to be coping perfectly well. AI can help by taking repetitive tasks off your hands. But if every saved hour is immediately filled with more work, where is the relief? Add the pressure to keep learning another tool and it can become another thing to feel behind on. We need to ask whether people’s days actually feel more manageable. 

We work with experienced people, so I can’t speak for a traditional junior agency structure. But years of experience don’t make anyone immune to uncertainty. What helps is understanding what AI means for the business and having time and support to learn. We’re bringing people onto our bench who have developed AI skills, while helping our existing community keep up. Experience and learning can go together. 

I wouldn’t assume managers are equipped to spot AI-related stress before it becomes burnout, or that someone will volunteer their worries. Looking capable and feeling comfortable can be very different things. Caring for people has always been central to my role; AI gives us another reason to check in properly. Ask what feels harder, what feels unclear and whether the tools are helping. Then be prepared to change the workload or expectations, rather than simply suggest another training session. 

The responsibility with changing roles is to be clear about what is changing, why, and what support people will have. Our founder, Jon Williams, has put a great deal of work into understanding AI and how we use it, and that understanding needs to be shared. We’re creating opportunities for people who have added AI to their skills. The aim is to help people see a way forward, rather than leave them guessing where they stand. 

My advice to agency leaders is much the same as what we’ve believed at Freedom Works and pay them properly. AI adds another layer to that responsibility. If it saves time, let people feel some benefit from it. A shorter to-do list would be a perfectly respectable technological breakthrough. 

   

An animated human head with colorful smoke coming out of it against a black background. The smoke is composed of different colors, creating a vibrant and dynamic effect.

Published by the IPA, the IPA AI Magazine helps member agencies make sense of the fast-changing AI landscape, with practical insights, expert perspectives and real-world applications of generative AI.
Managing Editor: Conor Nichols
Design: Jenna Betts

© 2026 The Institute of Practitioners in Advertising. All rights reserved. No part of this site may be reproduced without our permission.